SKW5002 Week 3 Assignment: Comparative Analysis of Child and Adolescent Testing Options

Comparative Analysis of Child and Adolescent Testing Options

Student name

Capella University

SWK5003

Professor Name

Submission Date

Application of Erikson’s Psychosocial Development Theory to the Character of Antwone Fisher

Childhood development is a necessary concern to determine the emotional, social, and psychological well-being of an individual. Movies that show the development of the child and their destiny will most likely offer some meaningful lessons about the development theories, which can be utilized to make predictions about human behavior.

The film Antwone Fisher is a movie by Denzel Washington that was broadcast in 2002 and provides a worthy example of psychosocial development. The movie is based on the real-life story of a young African American man, Antwone Fisher, who had served in the U.S Navy and failed to cope with his feelings and associations with other people because of his childhood traumatic experience. In this assignment, the Psychosocial Development Theory of Erik Erikson is used to track the developmental trajectory of Fisher and the crisis that he undergoes, the impact of the biological, psychological, and social forces, and how his developmental problems are resolved.

Character Overview and Presenting Problem

Antwone Fisher is a young sailor, in his early twenties, who appears tremendously disciplined yet incisively unbalanced emotionally. Fisher lost his father, who killed him, and his mother was taken to prison; being a foster child, he had to live with a lot of neglect, battering, and emotional trauma. His presenting problems are that he is likely to lose his temper with other people, is untrustworthy, has low self-esteem, and has problems of abandonment that were not resolved (Bogaerts et al., 2025). These are signs of a developmental impairment that he had gone through during his early years of life, especially in failing to establish a steady attachment and overcoming psychosocial crisis, as explained by Erikson in the child development model.

Overview of Erikson’s Psychosocial Development Theory

The psychosocial development theory developed by Erikson is a theory that exposes human beings to eight stages where psychosocial crisis takes place, and solutions to the crisis must be sought in all circumstances to have a healthy development. It is the struggle between two contrary psychological forces of trust and mistrust or autonomy and shame, and the resolution of the struggle leads to the appearance of the virtues that may help a man in his/her progress (Christie and Sandoval, 2024). The events that Fisher experienced could be best classified according to the first five stages developed by Erikson that make up the critical childhood and adolescent years. Erikson states that failure to reach those stages may lead to emotional and interpersonal problems during the adult stage, as was the case with Fisher.

Application of Erikson’s Theory to Antwone Fisher

Fisher has a broken trust versus mistrust level, which was driven during the early years of the said level. This is why he lacked the normal care and affection as an infant, and this explains why he tended to distrust other people and was also unable to establish safe attachment. At the autonomy vs. shame and doubt stage, the abusive supportive setting muted his capacity to generate independence and his trust. His encouragement was more of humiliation and penalties, which gave him a sense of insufficiency and the risk of losing (Huseyin Kotaman and Aslan, 2024).

The Abuse fear in Fisher limited the interest and the intent to explore during the initiative versus guilt phase. This brought about repressed leadership and the sense of guilt whenever he tried to force himself. The role models and internalized shame influenced him negatively in terms of his social and academic development. Lastly, this was the identity vs. role confusion stage, which had occurred in the teenage years, where Fisher had difficulties with identity definitions. The questions that were not, as such, clarified about his identity, his purpose, and his value had not been clarified about him with the assistance of the family support or identity, and he had been born into the world of manhood (Krabbendam et al., 2024).

Biological, Psychological, and Social Factors

Due to biological factors, excessive exposure to chronic stress and early trauma may have impacted the neurological maturity of Fisher, particularly in the areas that deal with emotional regulation. He has post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) signs and symptoms, such as anger, hyper vigilance, and emotionlessness. His rejection is due to the social isolation and other lack of relationships (Rorije et al., 2023). Nevertheless, the fact that he had an affair with the Navy psychiatrist, Dr. Jerome Davenport, who became his mentor, is a stepping stone. Dr. Fisher’s emotional experience that Fisher experiences is the remedial one, and it gives Fisher a second chance to trust people and cope with his trauma, which is presented by Davenport and his kindness and guidance.

Resolution of Developmental Crises

The therapy and self-reflection assist Fisher in overcoming his past and solving his psychosocial crises. He is in the process of transitioning to the identity versus role confusion identified by Erikson by reconciling with his baby mother and consequently achieving a feeling of identity that is not preconceived by his trauma. It is a life and death intervention of Dr. Davenport, which results in the healing of Fisher. He is affectionate but authoritative, which can give the emotional security that Fisher has never experienced as a child and proves that the emotional vacuum in terms of early development could be compensated in the form of a constant and trusted setting (Thain et al., 2024). The solution of Fisher is consistent with the thoughts of Erikson, who believes that individuals were not able to resolve their previous crisis; nevertheless, they are able to develop and re-heal in the later stages of their life.

Strengths and Weaknesses of Erikson’s Theory

Erikson’s theory is especially useful because it gives consideration to both the contribution of the surrounding or the social environment and psychological factors in the development of an individual. It offers us a complete insight into how the first experience influences subsequent behavior and states that we can become someone different throughout the lifespan (Christie and Sandoval, 2024). Nevertheless, it has a flaw since it is too broad; the stages suggested by Erikson are not always generalized to justify differences or even cultural differences. Moreover, the theory lacks full consideration of the biological element of the problem that involves neurodevelopmental consequences of the trauma that may manifest in the case of Fisher.

Integration into Social Work Practice

Such a conceptualization of child development, as suggested by Erikson, can do a lot in informing the capacity of a social worker to evaluate and assist the clients. In the situation with the subjects with different backgrounds (as in the case with Fisher), the interventions taken are sensitive and fair due to the consideration of the cultural and environmental contexts as a part of the assessment process. The developmental stages also make social workers sensitive, such that instilling resilience and bringing the clients towards self-actualization becomes very difficult.

Conclusion

The situation with Antwone Fisher’s narration is a clear example of how negative childhood development can be turned upside down in the adult age with the help of nurturing relationships and self-disclosure. Psychosocial Development Theory of Erikson, which is relevant to the life of Fisher, is a step-by-step process by which he failed to trust, identify, and belong. Although his story is based on the extent to which the original trauma has been stitched up, it shows that a human being is capable of growing and amending. The situation shows the significance of awareness building in helping the client to heal emotionally, not just his/her well-being, to the social workers.

Related Sample for this class: SKW5002 Week 2 Assignment